Labor Pains: Because Being in a Union can be Painful

  1. Teachers Want to Get Back in the Classroom — If Only Unions Would Let Them

    Despite pleas from parents and educators alike, teachers’ unions across the country have made one thing clear: Schools will only reopen at their say so, or not at all.

    The Fairfax Educators Association (FEA), a major teachers’ union in Virginia, is demanding that students stay out of the classroom until the end of the school year. Carla Okouchi, the union’s vice president, argued that this is the only way to keep the Fairfax community safe.

    United Teachers of Los Angeles (UTLA) has also fought against reopening efforts, demanding a slew of left-of-center policies be put in place before schools resume in-person learning. That includes “defunding the police, increasing taxes on the wealthy, [and] implementing Medicare for all.”

    But data shows that schools are not a significant source of coronavirus outbreaks. Just last month, Michael Osterholm, director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota, told the Washington Post that there have not been “explosive outbreaks of transmission in the schools,” as experts had once feared.

    Over the summer, YMCA Camps that provided care for the children of healthcare workers and first responders had just over one percent of staff test positive for COVID. Less than one percent of students tested positive for the virus. Elliot Haspel, an education policy expert and child care advocate, said there have been “almost no recorded cases of child-to-adult transmission of COVID-19.”

    The American Academy of Pediatrics even released guidance advising schools to reopen, highlighting the detrimental effects that school closures have had on children. They warned that students are receiving a subpar education and missing out on mental health resources, school nutrition programs, and socialization with their peers.

    The academy noted that students who suffer the most under distance learning are children from low-income and minority families. But that doesn’t seem to bother teachers’ unions.

    The FEA, UTLA, and other teachers’ unions advocating for distance learning are treating the coronavirus as a bargaining chip they’re unwilling to give up. Meanwhile, students and their teachers are being held hostage.

    That’s why a campaign from the Center for Union Facts called Speak Out For Teachers is collecting video testimonials from teachers who believe students need to return to safe, in-person learning as soon as possible.

    “Too many kids are sitting at home being depressed, being frustrated, being nervous. They need to be out and they need to be all together,” said one teacher from Carlsbad, California. Another teacher from Arizona summed it up perfectly: “What are we doing? We need to be back…let the union get out of the way.”

    Categories: Teachers UnionsUncategorized
  2. “Grassroots” Gig Workers Collective Exposed As UFCW Front

    Update: After this post went live, the Gig Workers Collective posted a response on its Facebook page. The post describes an even closer collaboration with the UFCW than we documented below. The Collective acknowledged that the union “directly [paid] Facebook for our newly launched ads” and has been “granted…access to our facebook (sic) page.” The Collective also said the UFCW “temporarily directly [hired] two of our long term volunteer organizers to help with the duration of the No On Prop 22 campaign.”  The Collective’s post argues that the UFCW managing and paying for its Facebook ads, as well as paying two of its organizers, does not compromise its independence from the union. Readers can decide for themselves whether this explanation adds up.

    The Gig Workers Collective’s cozy relationship with the UFCW was revealed through Facebook’s “page transparency” feature. The UFCW International in Washington, DC, is the sole entry on the list of “Organizations That Manage This Page.” UFCW is said to be “responsible” and has “claimed responsibility” for the Collective’s Facebook page. A phone number on the page connects to the UFCW’s press office in Washington. Presently, the Gig Workers Collective is running sponsored Facebook ads related to California’s Proposition 22 that say “Paid for by the United Food and Commercial Workers Union.” The UFCW is one of the top-three funders of the opposition campaign to Proposition 22, and has sought to organize workers in the gig economy.

    Members of the Gig Workers Collective have in the past denied being funded by the UFCW. Matthew Telles, an early member, said in February of this year that he is “not paid by the ufcw (sic) or anyone else for that matter.”

    While that may have been true at the time, the UFCW and other labor groups have been repeatedly connected to the Collective’s activities. This spring, Gig Workers Collective founder Vanessa Bain described “support from the UFCW and other partners” as being “crucial” to its mission. The Collective’s members have in the past worked extensively with Working Washington, a worker center backed by the SEIU that manages a national campaign to organize the gig economy. (Working Washington is the subject of an extensive complaint with the Office of Labor-Management Standards.)

    This isn’t the first time a purportedly “grassroots” worker group has been revealed to have union ties. The so-called Fight for $15, launched in 2012, was portrayed as a series of grassroots worker strikes; later financial reports filed with the Department of Labor revealed that the SEIU funded the protestspaid for public relations, and even used its fronts to make direct payments to the strikers. 

    Filings available next year with the Office of Labor Management Standards will provide greater detail on the UFCW International’s funding commitment. For now, the Gig Workers Collective deserves a permanent asterisk next to its “grassroots” description. As with other such groups, look for the union label.

    Categories: UFCWUncategorizedWorkers Center
  3. Labor Racket Weekly: Fall Roundup

    The seasons may be changing, but union bosses are still up to the same old tricks. Read more about this Fall’s best labor rackets below.

    In Missouri, Yvette Luster, former Treasurer of Postal Mail Handlers Local 314, was charged with one count of embezzlement of labor union assets in the amount of $184,138.

    In West Virginia, Cathy Byers, former Treasurer of American Federation of Teachers (AFT) Local 6540, was sentenced to eight months of home confinement and five years of supervised release. She was also ordered to pay a $100 special assessment. Byers previously paid $22,000 in restitution. On June 16, 2020, Byers pleaded guilty to one count of wire fraud in the approximate amount of $22,000.

    In Kentucky, Rocky Gannon, former President of American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE) Local 2302, was sentenced to 15 months of home incarceration, four years of probation, and 250 hours of community service. He was also ordered to pay $116,353 in restitution and a $1,200 assessment. On June 25, 2020, Gannon pleaded guilty to three counts of wire fraud and nine counts of forged securities.

    In North Dakota, Chad Michael Waldoch, former Secretary-Treasurer of Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation (SMART) Workers Local 980, was sentenced to 30 months of supervised release. He was also ordered to pay $50,270 and a $100 assessment. Waldoch previously paid $56,436 in restitution. On June 12, 2020, Waldoch pleaded guilty to one count of embezzlement of union funds in the amount of $107,707.

    In South Carolina, Dana Roush, former President of American Postal Workers Union (APWU) Local 403, was sentenced to 60 months of imprisonment and three years of supervised release. She was also ordered to pay restitution in the amount of $10,089. On October 22, 2019, Roush pleaded guilty to one count of embezzlement of union funds.

    In California, Marcus Asay, founder of the American Labor Alliance (ALA), was charged in a 19-count superseding indictment for wire fraud, mail fraud, conspiracy to commit mail fraud, and money laundering.

    In California, Antonio Gastelum, a former officer of the American Labor Alliance (ALA), was charged in a 19-count superseding indictment for wire fraud, mail fraud, conspiracy to commit mail fraud, and money laundering.

    In Indiana Superior Court, Misty Fain, former office manager for Laborers’ International Union of North America (LIUNA) Local 120, pleaded guilty to three counts of theft of union funds with a value of at least $750 and less than $50,000. Fain was then sentenced to one year in prison (suspended) and one year of probation. She was also ordered to pay restitution in the amount of $10,000.

    In Texas, Harold Bryan Weatherford, former Treasurer of National Staff Organization (NSO), Professional Staff Association, pleaded guilty to embezzlement of union funds totaling $82,560.

    In Texas, Edward C. Davis, Jr., former Secretary-Treasurer of Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen (BLET) Division 620, pleaded guilty to embezzlement in the amount of $61,386.

    In Texas, Edward C. Davis, Jr., former Secretary-Treasurer of Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen (BLET) Division 620, was charged in a criminal information with one count of embezzlement of union funds in the amount of $61,386.

    In New York, Brian Arnold, former Financial Secretary of United Steelworkers of America (USW) Local 104M, was sentenced to two years of probation including six months of home confinement with electronic monitoring. He was also ordered to pay $33,224 in restitution and a fine of $3,000. On June 9, 2020, Arnold pleaded guilty to one count of embezzlement of union funds.

    In New York, Kenneth Wynder Jr, former President of the Law Enforcement Employees Benevolent Association (LEEBA), was charged in a 13-count superseding indictment for wire fraud, conspiracy to defraud the United States, tax evasion, false statements to federal agents, and obstruction of a grand jury investigation.

    In New York, Steven Whittick, former Treasurer of the Law Enforcement Employees Benevolent Association (LEEBA), was charged in a 13-count superseding indictment for wire fraud, conspiracy to defraud the United States, tax evasion, false statements to federal agents, and obstruction of a grand jury investigation.

    Categories: Crime & CorruptionLabor Racket Weekly
  4. Former UAW Prez Williams Joins UAW Hall of Shame With Guilty Plea

    Last week, former United Auto Workers (UAW) President Dennis Williams became the 15th person to be convicted in the ongoing investigation into union corruption. He is the 11th UAW official overall to plead guilty, and the second former president.

    As an ad we’re running today in the Chattanooga Times Free Press states: “[Volkswagen] employees have twice rejected the UAW. With his guilty plea this week, the UAW’s former president demonstrated why.”

    The last we heard from Williams, he was being held at gunpoint while the FBI raided his home in California. Agents seized several items in the raid, including golf clubs and other golf merchandise. Now, he joins the UAW’s hall of shame for betraying workers’ trust.

    Williams tried to lay much of the blame on his fellow former President Gary Jones, saying of the union’s lavish expenses, “I knew in many cases such as golf and cigars, that there was no good-faith basis to think these expenses were for the benefit of our union.“

    When it came to these and other expenses, including stays at luxury resorts or dinner at five-star restaurants, it seems Williams easily overlooked any questions he had. All it took was Jones assuring him that all of the payments were “above board.” Jones himself recently pleaded guilty for helping embezzle almost one million dollars in members’ dues. Williams did admit that he made a “deliberate and conscious decision” not to actually check to see if Jones was telling the truth.

    The charge against him is punishable by up to five years in prison and a $250,000 fine. However, under his plea agreement, Williams may not see more than 24 months of prison time. We won’t know his final fate until he’s sentenced in January.

    Williams said he hopes that by accepting responsibility, he can help “restore faith” in the UAW. Good luck with that. His guilty plea is just the latest example of how the UAW failed its own members. With government oversight of the UAW still on the table, workers aren’t likely to forget Williams’ or any other union leaders’ crimes any time soon.

    Categories: UAWUncategorized
  5. Another One Bites the Dust at the UAW

    The ongoing federal probe into corruption in the ranks of the United Auto Workers (UAW) has taken down yet another union leader. Former UAW President Dennis Williams is set to plea guilty to his role in the union’s spending scandal at the end of the month.

    The indictment comes just a few months after another former union president Gary Jones’ own guilty plea. That’s right, Williams will be the second former UAW president to plead guilty to taking part in the wide-scale scheme to embezzle members’ dues money. Nine other high-ranking union officials have already been convicted. Overall, Williams is the 15th person to be charged in the federal investigation into wrongdoing at the union.

    The probe unearthed a long-standing scheme to funnel union funds to pay for luxury expenses, including “private villas, high-end liquor and meal expenses, golfing apparel, golf clubs and green fees.” Jones even spent $13,000 on cigars, and that was just in one instance. Other outrageous expenses included spa treatments for spouses, horseback riding on the beach, and sunglasses according to U.S. Attorney Matthew Schneider.

    Williams himself is charged with conspiring with six other union leaders to embezzle members’ dues. During the investigation, a luxury cabin was built for him at the UAW’s Black Lake resort. The cabin, which was built partly with the use of non-union labor, was officially taken back from Williams last year. The union was also paying Williams’ legal fees up until earlier this year, and has most recently forced the former president to pay back $56,000 in personal travel and lodging expenses. Now, Williams could face up to five years in prison and $250,000 in fines.

    In addition to a long-lasting black mark on the union’s record, the investigation could result in a decade-long period of government oversight at the UAW. Despite all this, presidential candidate Joe Biden still made a campaign appearance at the UAW Region 1 headquarters in Michigan last week. The UAW International Executive Board Vice President Gerald Kariem was also present at the event, just months after a federal lawsuit accused him of sexual harassment. 

    But, try as it might, the UAW can’t hide from its past. This latest conviction will probably discourage already-outraged auto workers from sticking with a union that has betrayed its own members.


    Categories: UAW
  6. UFCW Locals Keep Bylaws Out of Members’ Hands

    Among the more memorable examples of unions’ anti-transparency antics is the UFCW’s 2002 lawsuit to keep its constitution hidden from the public.

    Labor Notes reported in 2002:
    In February, the UFCW International had joined with UFCW Canada and Local 777 (now re-organized as Local 247) in an earlier lawsuit charging a UFCW shipping clerk with defamation and with copyright infringement for posting the union’s constitution on his web site.
    The defendant, William Gammert, says he published the constitution because he was denied a copy when he tried to run for local president. An affidavit by a former UFCW International official, Hugh Finnamore, supported Gammert’s allegations:
    “As a UFCW official, I worked with others to prevent members from obtaining copies of either the UFCW International Constitution or Local Union By-laws. As UFCW officials, we were suspicious of any member who asked for either document.”

    The courts eventually ordered the union to make the constitution public. But a member interested in locating bylaws for his or her UFCW local may still be in the dark.

    In an exhaustive search through the Office of Labor-Management Standards’ Online Public Disclosure Room (OPDR), the Center for Union Facts determined that 59 UFCW locals apparently failed to file a copy of their bylaws, as is required by the Labor Management Reporting and Disclosure Act (LMRDA). This week, CUF filed a complaint with OLMS asking the agency to investigate.

    What might these UFCW locals be trying to hide? Union bylaws give the local president the sole authority “to interpret the bylaws and rules of the Local Union.” At UFCW Local 881 in Chicago, for instance, late union President Ron Powell used his own interpretation of the bylaws to create an additional dues assessment on workers. Just three percent of the union’s represented workers voted in favor of the assessment, but because of Powell’s interpretation of the bylaws, he was able to enforce the new charge.

    The transparency provided by the public disclosure of these locals’ bylaws ensures union members know their rights and responsibilities. It’s time that members of these 59 UFCW locals receive that transparency.

    Categories: UFCWWorkers Center
  7. New Website Details Five Years of UFCW Spending, Including $6 Million to One Consulting Firm

    The Center for Union Facts is launching, a new website that highlights the United Food and Commercial Workers’ (UFCW) spending history. According to the site’s data, which was taken from the union’s LM-2 filings over the last five years (2015-2019), the UFCW has spent big on staff and officer salaries, luxury hotel stays, airline flights, and much more — all on its members’ dime.

    The website is part of an ongoing national education effort that aims to be a resource for current and potential union members who want to know how their union is spending members’ dues. Visitors to are invited to take an in-depth look at the last five years of UFCW spending information, watch a video explaining the union’s high-flying lifestyle, and hear a testimonial from a worker who fought to decertify the union.

    The UFCW has grown in prominence during the pandemic as one of the main unions representing essential workers, including grocery store clerks and meat packers. Union President Marc Perrone even penned an opinion piece alongside vice presidential nominee Kamala Harris. But the union has actually lost over 25,000 members since 2016 — likely because union membership isn’t the best deal for workers.

    In fact, according to one source, the UFCW International has a long history of questionable spending. A recent investigation found that over the last four years, the UFCW’s top leadership has “managed to siphon at least 6 million dollars in members money to a fund of questionable legitimacy.”

    These millions were paid to one consulting firm in particular in an attempt to bolster union membership. But, as this source notes, “since taking over in 2015, nothing has stopped the steady decline in membership of the UFCW for a net loss of 40,000 members realized under Perrone’s tenure.” So why was so much spent to achieve so little? Perhaps only Marc Perrone knows the answer to that question.

    According to the union’s LM-2 filings between 2015-2019, other spending includes:

    • $11 million on airline flights;
    • $19.8 million on hotels and events;
    • $5 million on lawyers;
    • $22 million on public relations and consulting;
    • $215 million in total compensation for employees and officers.

    Once they see the final bill on how the UFCW spends members’ dues, prospective members won’t be rushing to join, and current members will be looking for a way out.

    Categories: UFCW
  8. UAW Moves Closer to Teamsters-Style Government Monitoring

    After a years-long federal investigation into corruption in the ranks of the United Auto Workers (UAW), more than a dozen people have been convicted — most of them former UAW officials. Now, the threat of a government takeover of the union is one step closer to becoming a reality.

    This week, the U.S. Justice Department proposed subjecting the UAW to “10 years of federal oversight to eliminate corruption within the union.” The proposal comes after the latest guilty plea from former UAW President Gary Jones, who confessed to embezzling hundreds of thousands of members’ dues dollars. According to court documents, Jones was part of a multi-year scheme to divert money from the UAW for his personal use and the use of other UAW officials. Jones reportedly used the money to “splurge on private villas, golf outings, boozy meals and horseback rides on the beach.”

    As one analysis from a Penn State Harrisburg professor stated, “Removing the top leadership doesn’t necessarily lead to long-term change. Monitorship could be a healthy remedy.” Auto workers seem to agree. One UAW member at the Fiat Chrysler Automobiles Warren Truck Plant said a takeover was “definitely needed.” In fact, auto workers appalled by the union’s actions have already been calling for their own reforms. They formed a group called United All Workers for Democracy that aims to instate “one member, one vote” elections. The goal is to help members better hold their leadership accountable.

    Given this latest bout of bad press, it’s no wonder the union’s international leadership is avoiding the spotlight. The Democratic National Convention taking place this week would normally prompt participation from the UAW’s top leaders, especially considering presidential nominee Joe Biden’s stated commitment to bolstering the U.S. auto industry. Then-president Dennis Williams notably held court with reporters at the 2016 National Convention. In 2012, UAW President Bob King addressed the convention with an onstage speech. Alas, this year there’s been no sign of anyone from the union’s current headquarters.

    Instead, former president Bob King made a brief appearance, though it wasn’t in support of Joe Biden. Additionally, vice president of Michigan-based UAW Local 5960 is scheduled to speak. Perhaps the union hopes remarks from a local leader will be a distraction from the International’s misdeeds.

    Unfortunately for the UAW, this is far from the last negative headline regarding the union’s corruption scandal. But for the thousands of auto workers that are tired of the union’s tactics, a government takeover might be the perfect solution.

    Categories: UAWUncategorized